Puccini’s one-act opera may be set in the 17th century, but its tragic themes resonate powerfully with today’s realities, asserts Annilese Miskimmon from the English National Opera (ENO).
“Great operas thrive through constant reinvention,” Miskimmon explains. “These masterpieces transcend their original settings as new generations of directors, performers, and musicians breathe new life into them for modern audiences.”
She points out that the push to modernize an opera often stems from a desire to connect with a contemporary world that feels more relatable and vibrant. Conversely, some works that may have caused uproar upon their debut could benefit from a revolutionary reinterpretation, reminding us of their original power to shock. This approach bridges a composer’s initial vision with a future they couldn’t have predicted, highlighting how many were the avant-garde voices of their time. It could be both delightful and disturbing for them to realize they’ve become part of the very artistic establishment they once sought to challenge.
A prime example is Miskimmon’s latest semi-staged production of Puccini’s *Suor Angelica*, performed this week in honor of the composer’s centenary. This production is especially poignant as the opera delves into profound emotional and social turmoil.
Set in a convent, *Suor Angelica* narrates the story of Angelica, a nun who gave birth to an illegitimate child seven years earlier. After her family took her son away, she became a recluse, yearning for news about him. The opera unfolds in real-time over a single evening, revealing the stark reality of Angelica’s life when her aunt arrives with devastating news. Miskimmon captures the emotional depth of this piece, stating, “The opera grapples with the complexities of faith and forgiveness, immersing both singers and audiences in an emotional journey that only opera can evoke.”
Premiering in 1918 as part of *Il Trittico*, Puccini’s *Suor Angelica* was set in the late 17th century to navigate the societal discomfort surrounding its shocking narrative. For decades, critics dismissed it as overly sentimental and melodramatic. However, the ENO is presenting it as a powerful standalone piece, inviting audiences to rediscover its emotional intensity.
Miskimmon highlights that Puccini’s fascination with convent life was personal; his sister served as a Mother Superior in a Tuscan convent. Yet, as we navigate the complexities of 2024, Angelica’s story resonates deeply, especially amid ongoing discussions about historical abuses in Ireland.
“The Irish nation is grappling with the shame surrounding the treatment of over 80,000 unmarried mothers coerced into convent-run institutions from 1922 to 1998,” she shares. “Many were separated from their children at birth, forced to work without pay in Magdalene Laundries, forever severing bonds with their offspring.”
Miskimmon’s own family history intersects with this narrative—her maternal grandmother faced similar societal pressures in the 1930s, resulting in a secret marriage and a desperate struggle for autonomy. “It highlights how many families in Ireland bear scars akin to the tragic story presented in *Suor Angelica*,” she reflects.
She acknowledges that contemporary artists are confronting this national trauma through various mediums, including impactful films and series that address the ramifications of this period. Miskimmon’s reinterpretation of *Suor Angelica*, set in 1960s Ireland, sheds light on real-life stories that mirror Angelica’s fictional plight, amplifying the opera’s emotional landscape.
Interestingly, when Puccini first shared his work with the nuns of his sister’s convent, he witnessed tears in their eyes during the performance. “My experience reflects this sentiment in 2024,” Miskimmon states. “We carry forward the legacy of those who suffered, honoring their stories through art.”
*Suor Angelica* will be presented at the London Coliseum on September 27, with performances at 6 PM and 8:15 PM.
About the author